Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
Ok, gear ratios are a bit tricky but I found a great bit of information on "How Stuff Works."...
So, to get the actual gear ratio of a specific gear box, from 1-2 you count the number of teeth on the 1st gear and divide it by the number of teeth on the 2nd gear....and so on (2-3, 3-4, 4-5...). The higher the initial gear ratio, the more pull off the line the car can have.
Here's our gear ratio setup: Final-drive ratio: 4.24:1 Gear, Ratio, Mph/1000 rpm, Max test speed I, 3.54, 4.7, 29 mph (6200 rpm) II, 2.05, 8.2, 51 mph (6200 rpm) III, 1.33, 12.6, 78 mph (6200 rpm) IV, 0.97, 17.2, 107 mph (6200 rpm) V, 0.78, 21.6, 127 mph (5900 rpm) For our final drive to be 4.24:1, that means our motor has 4.24 full revelutions to make just to get the tire to make 1 full revelution. Compared to a Porsche 911 Turbo: Final Drive 3.44:1 1st Gear Ratio 3.82:1 2nd Gear Ratio 2.05:1 3rd Gear Ratio 1.41:1 4th Gear Ratio 1.12:1 5th Gear Ratio 0.92:1 6th Gear Ratio 0.75:1 Amazingly, our gear ratio isn't far off from the 911 setup. It has a higher 1st gear ratio, so it will explode more from the start, has more in the middle gears as well and a similar final gear setup. Only thing is, it's got a final drive of 3.44 so it takes about 1 less engine rotation to get the tire spinning than it does ours. As you can see, it's all like a bike gear setup. You start off in the biggest gear b/c that's where you get more of a 1:1 (not exact but closer) engine to power delivery conversion. If you started in the highest gear of a bike, you'll notice that it takes less rotations to spin the rear tire but a LOT more force to get it spinning. Same concept in cars. Start on the big gear b/c from the start, it takes less power to get spinning and can get you moving faster with less power. As you move up in the gears, the ratio actually drops b/c the gear size from the previous gear to the next is getting smaller. With the engine (or the person on the bike) in full rotation now, the smaller the gears means that the engine can utilize the power it's creating by allowing the smaller gears to spin the tires at a higher rate with less actual rotation. As you get closer to the end, the gears are much smaller than when you started, which allows the engine to spin less but to have more power delivered to the ground with less effort. In the FINAL drive ratio, you are in the smallest gear and that's where (as stated above) you are spinning the engine as little as possible to get the most forward motion out of the vehicle. Please ask questions if necessary. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Mayo
Reg'd: Feb 14, 2007 The Guru |
Wow Web, you've done it again. Very good stuff. So let me relate this to other concepts. In the write up, there was something that said that if the initial gear ratio is higher, it will start off the line faster. Or something to that effect. So does that mean its better to use the cars "peak torque" when in the gears with a gear ratio higher than one? If my years of physics classes serve me, because the engine is using a larger gear to turn a smaller one, it requires more torque. ![]() "gonna wash my car before i take a nap.. can't rest well knowing i've got the entire cast of A Bug's Life on my bumper" - Vicious -- Want to post a "For Sale" thread? Check out the rules first. |
|
|
|
Mayo
Reg'd: Feb 14, 2007 The Guru |
Oh god. I got the idea of gear ratios backwards. Nevermind what I had just said. No wonder it wasn't making sense to me. ![]() "gonna wash my car before i take a nap.. can't rest well knowing i've got the entire cast of A Bug's Life on my bumper" - Vicious -- Want to post a "For Sale" thread? Check out the rules first. |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
hahaha..............well, you want a higher gear initially b/c torque is what gets you off the line. As you advance the gears, your engine hp (continuous and building power supply) is what keeps the gears turning and that's why you can go so smaller gears. The hp keeps the engine turning and increasing after it gets started. The torque is what gets it moving from the start in the higher gear. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Mayo
Reg'd: Feb 14, 2007 The Guru |
Alright, I think I found out what was confusing me. Straight from Wikipedia:
which seems to contradict:
See what its saying? The statements contradict each other! ![]() "gonna wash my car before i take a nap.. can't rest well knowing i've got the entire cast of A Bug's Life on my bumper" - Vicious -- Want to post a "For Sale" thread? Check out the rules first. |
|
|
|
Orin
Reg'd: Dec 08, 2005 |
thanks for making this, I can honestly say I know more about gear ratios after reading this |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
The problem is, most examples detail an almost 1:1 power delivery system. The engine spins 1 time and the wheels spin 1 time. But, we also have to take into acount the gears for the transmission will add to that and actually cause more engine rotation per tire rotation. if you take the transmission out or have a single gear transmission that has a gear that matches the overall gear output of the engine, then you will be almost 1:1. But, since it's almost impossible to have that, although some cars come REALLY close, we have to deal with what we have now. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Orin
Reg'd: Dec 08, 2005 |
so in a ratio of 2.05 : 1 that 2.05 is the number of the engine revolution? RPM? |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
That is simply the ratio of the two gears that it is describing. Perfect is 1:1 and that's when both gears you are looking at have the exact same amount of teeth/diameter. That means for each revolution of one, the other does 1 revolution also. 2.05:1 means: One gear is of a specific diameter/tooth count, and the other divided by the lower gear (previous gear) becomes 2.05:1. So, it takes 2.05 engine revolutions to make 1 revolution in the gear box. YES, to answer your question ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Mayo
Reg'd: Feb 14, 2007 The Guru |
Alright another question thats been bothering me. Its hard to make it tC specific, some Im going to use simply a general car example. Say it takes a car about 1.5 seconds to get from 10mph to 20mph (2nd gear, 2k rpm to 3k rpm) But that same car takes 3 seconds to get from 50mph to 60mph (5th gear, 2k rpm to 3k rpm) ^ That may not be a tC, but its decently realistic for a car. Same amount of throttle for both examples. My question is why it takes longer to go from 50-60mph than it does from 10-20mph. If you think about it, the gear ratio in 2nd gear is much larger than the gear ratio in 5th gear. 5th gear makes fewer engine strokes per wheel revolution. So shouldn't 50-60 mph be faster than 10-20 mph? (I know its not, haha, but what the hell am I missing?) ![]() "gonna wash my car before i take a nap.. can't rest well knowing i've got the entire cast of A Bug's Life on my bumper" - Vicious -- Want to post a "For Sale" thread? Check out the rules first. |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
Ok.........as you move up in gears, it's easier for the gears to spin b/c they are smaller BUT.....it takes more engine revolutions to make them complete 1 full spin. So....2nd gear only takes that little time b/c the larger gear spins closer to that 1:1 ratio with the engine and transmission compared to 5th gear. The further you get from 1:1 power utilization, the more power it's going to take (and time) to utilize the power output. The higher gears have smaller diameter/tooth count gears so it takes more engine revolutions to get those smaller transmission gears to be able to transfer that power from the engine to the wheels. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
In the higher gears, that is where Horsepower comes into play. It takes more Horsepower to go from 50-60 than it does to go from 10-20. That's another reason why going from 100-120 takes longer than 50-60........gear ratio (final drive gear) is the main reason but Horsepower is considered in that as well. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
|
lemire04
Reg'd: Feb 18, 2007 Oil Changer |
kinda like when your riding your bike in the highest gear: you peddle 50 times and only go two feet? |
|
|
|
Mayo
Reg'd: Feb 14, 2007 The Guru |
Thanks for taking the time to explain. I hope other people are wondering the same thing cause I feel dumb asking. Just making sure you realize how thoroughly confused I am, heres my train of thought: 2000-3000 rpms in 2nd gear (2:1) yields 'X' wheel revolutions 2000-3000 rpms in 5th gear (0.5:1) yields '>X' wheel revolutions becauce the gear receiving the power from the engine is smaller, making the wheels spin faster. ![]() "gonna wash my car before i take a nap.. can't rest well knowing i've got the entire cast of A Bug's Life on my bumper" - Vicious -- Want to post a "For Sale" thread? Check out the rules first. |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
Yeah, when you're in 1st chain and 1st gear, the gears are almost the same diameter so that's why you can spin the hell out of the tire but you don't really go anywhere. To counter that, you need to be able to multiply the amount of force YOU are producing to the rotational force the bike/gears are producing. This is where the smaller gears come into play. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Orin
Reg'd: Dec 08, 2005 |
I suppose another simpler way to look at it is lower gears like first require the engine to spin more to turn it smaller gears like 5th allow your engine to relax because not as many revolutions are required to spin it |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
That's where you're confusing yourself. The ENGINE is what's spinning faster and not the transmission gear. The transmission gears spin faster in LOWER gears, not higher gears. Just like a mountain bike. The higher you go in gears requires MORE force from you to go even faster. If you could spin the highest gear of a bike at the rate that you spin the lowest gear (1:1 respectively), you would be able to cruise at a HIGH speed and have HUGE quads. Just like cars, it takes more power to go faster when you're in a higher gear b/c of the ratio to engine/pedal gear compared to transmission/tire gear. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
Key thing...........the faster you go in each increasing gear takes more horsepower than the previous/lower gear to continue forward. ![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|
Mayo
Reg'd: Feb 14, 2007 The Guru |
Oh man does that clear things up. Thanks. ![]() "gonna wash my car before i take a nap.. can't rest well knowing i've got the entire cast of A Bug's Life on my bumper" - Vicious -- Want to post a "For Sale" thread? Check out the rules first. |
|
|
|
Web
Reg'd: Apr 17, 2006 THE SHADOW |
![]() Ignorance is bliss....305 fo life!...haha...Poser |
|
|
|